fiction

Are membership organisations in danger of becoming obsolete?

Richard Walker on the role research and insight can play in navigating membership challenges in 2025 and beyond.

Membership organisations come in many shapes and sizes. Despite that, the challenges (and the solutions) are remarkably similar. That’s handy for us. It allows us to keep this blog fairly generic whilst protecting our client anonymity. That’s also handy for you.  Whether you’re reading this as a professional / vocational institute, society or association, a sports organisation / governing body, a charitable organisation, a Union, or from within the arts, culture, conservation space, the chances are – if you have a membership to serve – you are likely to be facing similar issues.

Here are some of the problems membership organisations have been approaching us with recently. Do they sound familiar?

  • Passive membership not contributing or volunteering
  • Members cancelling or not renewing
  • Difficulty attracting, retaining new / younger members
  • Price sensitivity combined with inflationary pressures
  • Keeping up with member expectations on social and ethical issues
  • The challenges associated with digital transformation
  • Value propositions that no longer serve their purpose
  • Brand creep and a dilution of purpose caused by a lack of focus
  • Content overexposure and the challenge for attention

As we look towards the second half of the decade and beyond, membership bodies must confront these challenges head-on. This means having solid and realistic strategies for retention and acquisition. This means ensuring the product mix and member benefits are fit for purpose and perceived as having value. And it means ensuring you are investing in the brand and fit-for-purpose engagement and communication plans – giving members what they need, at the right time and in the right way.


Mustard has been doing a lot of work in this area, which means you probably have been (or should be) too! Here are nine questions you probably need to be asking of your membership (if you haven’t already).

1. What do our members ACTUALLY want in 2025 and beyond?
Have you even asked? If you think you know what members want – do you know whether you’re considered as the best option for delivering this – or are members looking elsewhere? If so, why? The fact is, a LOT has changed. The ways in which people work and develop their careers especially. Professional membership organisations, in particular, need to get a handle on what networking and events look like in a world of hybrid working. What can you offer that is more accessible and more “bite sized” to maintain engagement? Our work in this area has included helping organisations find the optimum balance between tangible and intangible member benefits and assessing the extent to which membership is (perceived to be) making a discernible difference.

2. Which membership organisations are delivering best-in-class experiences?
People make more and more cross-sector comparisons, expectations are rising, and they will happily judge B2B experiences according to what they might expect in a B2C environment (and vice versa). Take inspiration from outside your bubble. Digital experience also plays a big role across sectors – outdated digital platforms and cumbersome user experiences lead to lower engagement and frustration among members. Members expect interactive, quick and easy, mobile-friendly  “self-service” solutions.

3. How much are members willing to pay for the right product and the right experience?
In the face of declining membership numbers (or as a means of reaching ambitious growth targets) some of our clients have been reevaluating membership tiers. Some membership bodies face stiff competition from free or lower-cost alternatives, leading to challenges in recruitment. Research has a key role to ensure you are charging what is considered a fair price for the benefits being offered. Fundamentally, this means ensuring you have a clearly defined (and well communicated) unique value proposition. Consider leveraging social proof, testimonials, and case studies to showcase success stories. Also, what might a trial membership look like to give potential members a taste of the benefits? Our work in this area shows that confusion often reigns when it comes to multiple membership tiers, and that members prefer whatever is considered the clearest and easiest to understand value proposition. Be mindful, also, not to design membership tiers that feel exclusive or might cause resentment amongst other members.

4. How do we engage younger members?
Membership organisations – and professional bodies in particular – are under increasing pressure from shifting demographics, changing expectations, and growing competition from digital platforms. Younger members demand AI-driven, flexible, digital-first offerings that provide immediate value. This can leave some traditional membership models struggling to keep up. What worked for you in the nineties and noughties probably isn’t going to work for the next generations. Our previous work in this area has highlighted the importance of being especially mindful of the unique challenges experienced at different life-stages and career stages, so ensure that you are switched on to helping those that are the most time poor.

5. What does personalisation look like in a membership organisation like ours?
There is a growing demand for (and expectation of) personalisation across all walks of life – membership organisations are no different. To what extent are you set up to deliver this? Some of our clients are offering apps for better accessibility and are implementing AI-driven personalisation to recommend content, events, or networking opportunities based on user behaviours. But make sure you understand the “who” and the “why” before embarking on the “how”, and consider using segmentation or personas to tailor to the needs and interests of cohorts.

6. Why are our members REALLY leaving (and how do I stop it!)?
You may well have an exit survey – but is this giving you the full story? Do you understand the REAL reasons, or are they telling you what they think you want to hear? Have you explored the emotional triggers and the “small stuff” they have been sweating (that often, actually, makes the biggest difference)?

7. What positive steps can we make to drive retention?
Once you know and understand why members leave, research will allow you to understand what kinds of changes will make the biggest difference on retention rates. Moving beyond a point where members feel they “have to” have membership through necessity. Delving into the relative value associated with membership tiers is essential.

Our previous work has included drivers analysis to understand which benefits are “essential” in driving membership satisfaction and renewals vs what is “nice to have”.  Other clients are driving retention through personalised engagement strategies and member-only exclusive content, networking events, and professional development opportunities that encourage renewals. Again, key to this is value perception, and also responsiveness.

8. How do we convert members into advocates?
Get it right, and your membership themselves can be your primary recruitment tool. Listening to your members should be an ongoing process. By regularly consulting with them through surveys, focus groups, or online communities, you stay attuned to their evolving needs. Engaged members are more likely to renew their memberships and act as advocates for your organisation.

Continuous consultation also helps you identify and solve problems before they impact member retention. For example, if younger members feel that the value isn’t clear or relevant to their current needs, you can adapt your offerings and messaging to drive appeal. A third consideration here is having a clear purpose. Regardless of the type of membership organisation, people want to align themselves with brands that are credible, have a strong reputation and are “like-minded”. Actions that diminish that reputation can have a big impact on the appeal of membership. They want you to have a point of view, and they want you to champion the things they are passionate about themselves. This MUST come across strongly in communications and is important in delivering those intangible membership benefits.

9. What about the mid-long term future for our membership organisation?
The future of membership bodies hinges on their ability to innovate. The needs of your membership and prospective members is continually evolving. Your audience expects you to be leading and not following. As such, research has an ongoing role to play in shaping the longer term future of your organisation ensuring it remains fit-for-purpose. This is likely to include revamps and refreshments of membership models, further digital transformation and personalisation. Those that continually adapt based on insight and futures forecasting will be better equipped to attract and retain members, ensuring long-term sustainability.

These are big, strategic questions that are likely to shape your future destiny, and they may determine whether you’re destined to be thriving, just surviving, or worse.

Remember, however, that research also plays a role in getting the tactics right:

  • From a content perspective, what are the themes and subjects of greater (or lesser) interest? What is “interesting” versus “useful”?
  • To what extent are different audiences preferring digital vs., in-person events. What are the “rules” which causes one to win out over the other?
  • What is causing some comms to perform better than others? How can the communications be more relevant and more engaging?
  • Where are the threats and where is the “blue water” of opportunity in terms of products and services?  Why should they choose your organisation over one of the multitude of online platforms offering networking,  and professional development or insurance / indemnity?


What type of research should I be doing?

At Mustard, we’re fairly method agnostic. The research methods are just the means-to-an-end, but if you’re new to research and need some inspiration, we’re here to help.

Quantitative research – online surveys or phone surveys – for when you need measures, and your questions tend to start with “how many”, “which” or “what”. We put the onus on data quality, and have in-house stats expertise to work the data harder.

Qualitative research – in-depth interviews, ethnographic / observational methods, online communities and focus groups – for when you need depth of understanding, and your questions tend to start with “why”, or “how”. For when you need the deeper unfiltered insights, and access to the emotions – unmet needs, frustrations, experiential expectations, etc.

More often that not, our work with membership organisations incorporates a “hybrid” of quant and qual methods – generating the concreate evidence to shape decision making.

Another consideration would be segmentation. No membership is homogenous – they have different needs, motivations and attitudes, and of course they behave differently too. Segmentation needn’t be expensive, and provides a solution to many of the challenges highlighted previously (such as acquisition and retention, personalisation, engagement and advocacy, tiering, etc.).


So, are membership organisations in danger of becoming obsolete?

Back to the opening question, Are membership bodies in danger of becoming obsolete? The answer largely depends on how well organisations can adapt to the changing needs of their members. Are you willing to ask the uncomfortable questions and confront the difficult answers?

Our verdict? Absolutely NOT -IF you are willing to embrace change and acknowledge that hard decisions might be required to future proof your organisation to meet the needs of the next generation of members. Those that listen and adapt will not just survive, but will be able to thrive.

But staying relevant is essential. Those that don’t keep up will inevitably be in danger.

To succeed in this evolving landscape, you must understand members better than ever before. Market research, both quantitative and qualitative, can provide the insights needed to future-proof your organisation and maintain relevance in the long-term.


Drop us an email or give us a call for some membership research therapy. You’re not alone in facing these challenges, and we’re great listeners.